In a side note in his History of...

Issue #234

In a side note in his History of Economic AnalysisJoseph Schumpeter anticipated the idea of a ‘scientific paradigm’, which has later been introduced by Thomas S. Kuhn in his Structure of Scientific Revolutions. The latter has been published in 1962, that is, eight years after the first edition of the History had been printed. However, instead of a ‘paradigm’, Schumpeter speaks of a “preanalytic cognitive act” or a “vision”, that precedes any “analytic effort” (p. 41).

Thereby, it comes as no surprise that such a “preanalytic vision” also carries some normative baggage: it leads us to emphasize some problems over others (e.g. unemployment over sustainability, or efficiency over unemployment and the like) and to inspect some aspects more closely than others (e.g. do we look at the welfare gains or the environmental hazards emerging from international trade?). Effectively, it was one of the great achievements of Gunnar Myrdal to point out this aspect – that every economic paradigm is related to some political doctrine and that analytical ideal types and political ideals are often mutually related – already in the 1930s (see here).

Against this backdrop, I found it very delighting to read the recent study on the political identity of economists and its relation to their perception of the stability of capitalism published in the Review of Radical Political Economy. The authors show how the political identity of economists acts as a suitable predictor for answers given on more ‘foundational’ questions related to our economic system. The latter include questions on its ecological and financial stability, the nature of the business cycle or current distributional trends. It helps to show to what extent the mainstream of the discipline tends to share the concerns voiced at its margins (e.g. in the context of ecological or distributional questions) and where it strongly disagrees with more radical views (e.g. in case of the question “does capitalism tend towards monopoly?”). And finally, studies like these shed some light on why alternative approaches to teaching in research in economics are often confronted with hostility (see here for a current example) - simply because they implicitly question or challenge the dominance of certain “preanalytical visions” over others.

In sum, the original material presented in the paper indicates nicely, how our perceptual and conceptual awareness is often too closely tied to our most favorite theoretical assumptions. It is a study in the tradition of Schumpeter, Kuhn and Myrdal, and it is one of those studies that is enlightening, not because its results are so surprising, but, on the contrary, because it provides some systematic and independent confirmation on what is tacitly obvious anyway.

All the best,
Jakob