So, Omikron is what we now call the...

Issue #289

So, Omikron is what we now call the next step in the pandemic cycle. Sounds rigorous and was maybe unavoidable but still, the probability of such an event could have been massively reduced if vaccines were available in the Global South at the same scale as they are in the Global North. This outcome is mainly the result of rich countries trying to jointly maximize their public health as well as their profits by hoarding vaccines and by protecting their intellectual property rights. In my view, this strategy was bound to fail even when taking the (revealed) opportunistic preferences of the Global North as given. The reason is simply that any large-scale diffusion of COVID acts as a facilitator for new mutations that will eventually find their way also into those countries which are located far away from such large-scale exposures. Hence, the opportunist strategy does not deliver as it systemically undermines the very same protection it was intended to provide.

If it were not somewhat tragic and, hence, emotionally distracting, it would make a good teaching example for how opportunistic strategies may quickly backfire when applied to social problems that can, at least to some extent, be rationalized as collective action problems. Moreover, this observation also teaches a double lesson in ethics: for one, the implications of the consequentialist approach (i.e., a focus on outcomes, which is also the prominent approach in economics) strongly depend on who is included in the equation, that is, on whose outcomes count. Needless to say that a more inclusive consequentialist notion – say, the old-fashioned one, where everybody’s outcome counts – would easily have led rich countries to different decisions.

For another, we also observe that the opportunistic stance is not invulnerable. Rather, it is subject to uncertainty as we have to deduce or guess the outcomes of our actions in advance to anticipate potential outcomes – and these guesses might be in error. Eventually, we might achieve a quite different outcome than we originally hoped to achieve and it is in this context, that a strategy may backfire. To me, this seems to be the case here, although the original hope to achieve higher net safety by betting on national opportunism was, most probably, an all too naïve bet anyway. In contrast, a more virtue-based line of action – that is a focus on moral principles instead of anticipated outcomes – guided by the conventional ideas on human rights would have implied a more inclusive strategy. Eventually such a more inclusive strategy would also have served to benefit the Global North, but, as it seems, too few policy-makers have anticipated that one ;-)

In this spirit: not only stay healthy, but also share and care.

Best

Jakob

PS: Due to the holiday break the next Newsletter will be delayed for a week and arrive in your mailbox on January 3, 2022. Stay tuned!